30 “Picky Eaters” Show Off Their Highly Questionable Go-To Meals

The food combinations some people enjoy can certainly be surprising.

We all know someone with an unconventional favorite, like peanut butter and pickle sandwiches.

Recently, we delved into the “Picky Eaters” subreddit and came across various unique go-to meals that self-proclaimed “picky eaters” prefer.

From carrot dogs to unusual Chipotle orders, the spectrum of peculiar tastes is vast. It just goes to show that taste is deeply personal and varies significantly from one person to another.


1. “When You Need To Use Up The Stuff In The Freezer”

via reddit

2. “My New Hyper Fixation Meal: Mini Baguette Served With Spaghetti Tossed In Rao’s Alfredo Sauce”

via reddit

3. “That’s How I Eat Burgers, Just Bland Meat And Buns With Nothing, Am 18 Btw”

via reddit

4. “I Scrubbed The Icing Off My Cookie Because It Was Too Sweet”

via reddit

5. “Feast Your Eyes On My 3 Weeks Worth Of Dinners Which I Meal Prepped Today”

via reddit

6. “Any Other Pb Only Sandwich People Out There?”

via reddit

7. “Dinner”

via reddit

8. “My mom made stewed ossobuco, but I’m not a fan of meat, though I do enjoy chicken breast and turkey sausages. Instead, I mixed 1/4 of a white onion with white vinegar, olive oil, and salt.”

via reddit

9. “Nothing Says ‘Picky Eater’ Like Ordering Off The Child’s Menu And Getting Sangria”

via reddit

10. “A Picky 7 Year Old Idea Of A ‘Nice’ Dinner”

via reddit

11. “Lifesaver For When My Texture Adversity Acts Up”

via reddit

12. “That How I Eat Chicken Sandwich From Mcdonalds…”

via reddit

13. “Ah Yes, Gardien Chicken Nuggets And Green Beans. A Meal Fit For A Picky Toddler”

via reddit

14. “My Beige Diet”

via reddit

15. “Proper Picky Tea!”

via reddit

16. “My Sister’s ‘Picky Lunch’. What Poor Choices Have You Made Because Of The Heatwave?”

via reddit

17. “My Brother Is A Picky Eater…”

via reddit

18. “When Its Been A Long/S**tty Day At Work. Nothing Relaxes Me More Than A Kid’s Dinner And An Early Night”

via reddit

19. “I’m A Very Picky Eater So It Means A Lot When O Say That This Is Some Tasty Meal”

via reddit

20. “Packed Breakfast And Lunch For The Super Picky Kid- Air Fryer Chicken Strips And Fries, Cheese Cubes, Cheez-Its, And Fruit Snacks”

via reddit

21. “My Overly Picky Toddlers ‘Pizza'”

via reddit

22. “Found A Veggie Soup I Love! It’s A Miracle!”

via reddit

23. “This Is My Picky-Eating, Co-Worker’s Chipotle Order”

via reddit

24. “My Mom Made This For My Super Picky Brother”

via reddit

25. “Meal Prep For A Diet I Had To Do”

via reddit

26. “Love Beige Foods – Tostadas, Refried Beans, Tofurkey, Fyp Parm”

via reddit

27. “Carrot Dogsss”

via reddit

28. “As A Lazy Poor Picky Eater Student I Have So Many These Ffs”

via reddit

29. “Trying Chips And Dip. I Want To Like It But It Feels Like My Brain Says No? The Look Of The Dip Is Not Helping”

via reddit

30. “Parents Always Said I’m Just Picky. What Do You Think”

via reddit
Nate

Nate Armbruster

Nate Armbruster is a stand-up comedian and writer based in Chicago who is likely writing a joke as you read this. Find him online at natecomedy.com.