In the world of Harry Potter movies or the books, fans have long debated whether Harry’s success comes down to raw wizarding skill or sheer, dumb luck. Did he win those battles with actual magical talent, or was he just fortunate enough to have friends like Hermione and Dobby covering his back?
This thread dives deep into the debate, with fans on both sides sharing their best arguments. From his surprising Quidditch wins to his final showdown with Voldemort, was it really skill or did he just have a supernatural amount of good timing? Here’s what hardcore Potterheads had to say.