“That’s It, I’m Cake Shaming” — 40 Funny Cake Fails That Got Baked In The Comments

If you’ve ever tried baking a cake and ended up with something that looks more like a crime scene than dessert, congratulations—you’d fit right in with the folks over at That’s It, I’m Cake Shaming and Cake Wrecks.

These Facebook groups are a chaotic buffet of funny cake fails, cake decorating disasters, and frosting nightmares that make you wonder how we got here as a society.

These aren’t your Pinterest-perfect desserts. These are the kinds of baking fails that make you say, “Nailed it,” but with tears in your eyes and cake under your fingernails.

Perfect for anyone who’s ever tried to DIY a birthday cake and ended up emotionally attached to a deflated unicorn made of buttercream.


1. “Found This One In ‘Just Disney'”

via facebook

2. “Found This. It Would Be Something I Would Totally Do Probably Make The Cake Out Of Dog Food”

via facebook

3. “He Might Be A Little Beyond Help”

via facebook

4. “Looks Like Poor Chip Had A Stroke”

via facebook

5. “I Love This One And Hate It At The Same Time”

via facebook

6. “Hmmm…. Pickle Cheesecake With Pretzel Crust”

via facebook

7. “Nightmare Fuel Right Here”

via facebook

8. This is supposed to be the Eiffel Tower

9.

via facebook

10. “Ummm….what? This Unicorn Has See Some Things In Life”

via facebook

11. “My Mom Ordered And Paid For It But When She Got To The House And Looked At It, We All Quickly Realized That This Was Not The Sentiment We Were Hoping To Celebrate. Happy Mothday To All You Moths Out There”

via facebook

12. “Found In The Wild… Someone Even Commented, “Nice…but Please Don’t Quit Your Day Job””

via facebook

13. “The Likeliness Is Uncanny”

via facebook

14. “A Duck Cake, Or Paralysis Demon…?”

via facebook

15. “Sorry This Made Me Giggle”

via facebook

16. “A Cake From A Local Baker. Normally, Her Cakes Are So Well Done!”

via facebook

17. “Hmmmmm”

via facebook

18. “Oh. Oh My”

via facebook

19. “Honestly The Cake Looks Good But That Topper”

via facebook

20. “Finally Stumbled Upon Something To Share Here”

via facebook

21. “This Was Her Last Custom Order Cake Of 2023 And Lets Hope Forever!”

via facebook

22. “Wha… What Is This Supposed To Be?!”

via facebook

23. “I Think This Cake Has Seen Some Things”

via facebook

24. “Who S**t On The Cake”

via facebook

25. “I Feel Like It’ll Look The Same Way Coming Out”

via facebook

26. “Apparently This Is Not A Joke”

via facebook

27. “From A Professional Bakery”

via facebook

28. “Terrifying!!”

via facebook

29. “I Mean It’s Never Too Late To Uninvite Someone To Your Wedding, A Mum Is No Exception”

via facebook

30. “Tapeworms? Caramelized Onions?? Who Knows???”

via facebook

31. “Found This On My Local Marketplace”

via facebook

32. “I Hope It’s Also Your Last”

via facebook

33. “Hmmmmm”

via facebook

34. “Oh No A Coworker Of Mine Made This For Her Sister’s Wedding”

via facebook

35. “Stumbled Across The Stitch One On My Feed As The Page Was Suggested”

via facebook

36. “My Cousin Posted This”

via facebook

37. “Spotted In The Wild On My Facebook Feed This MorningI Have So. Many. Questions”

via facebook

38.

39.

40.

More funny food: 40 Funny Food Tweets That’ll Made Us Laugh Away The Calories This Week (May 30, 2025)

Nate

Nate Armbruster

When he's not doomscrolling Twitter or writing for Pleated-Jeans, Nate Armbruster writes jokes—and then tells them on stage as a stand-up comedian, where he can watch audiences (hopefully) laugh in real-time.