After a church potluck, Mom found a perfect square cut out of her shirt. Years later, after another.

30 Personal Mysteries People Still Think About Years Later

Add as a preferred source on Google

If I lose something in my own house, I give myself about ten minutes before I start interrogating people. “Have you seen my headphones?” is usually the last thing I say before realizing I’m wearing them.

That’s the sort of detective work I’m bringing to this list. Which is a shame, because I’d genuinely like to solve a few of these.

These people in this AskReddit thread shared the questions they still don’t have answers to. I hope at least one of them sends this around to the family. Somebody’s had years to come clean.

1. Who Went To See Hitch?

My parents owned what I consider to be my childhood home from 2001 through 2015.

When helping them move out in 2015, we cleared the finished basement where I found a Loews movie theater ticket stub from our hometown for the 2005 comedy, Hitch, starring Will Smith and Kevin James.

Now, I’ve never seen Hitch, let alone in theaters. My parents never saw Hitch. My older sister and only sibling was away at college (the ticket stub was dated in February 2005). She also denies ever watching Hitch in theaters.

Where did the ticket stub come from? Who saw Hitch? Who brought the ticket stub to the house after seeing Hitch?

YesterdayWasAwesome

2. The Church Potluck Mystery

My parents hosted two small church potlucks at our house twice, a few years apart in two different places, hundreds of miles apart with two entirely different groups of people.

The first time, everyone left and the next day my mom discovered someone cut a perfect 1.5” by 1.5” square out of the middle of one of her shirts in her room.

Few years later at the next event, someone cut a perfect square of similar size out of a sentimental baby bib that was kept at the bottom of a drawer in the kitchen with other special linens.

No one knows who it could’ve possibly
been. Both groups of people were fairly small, and were close family friends.

Edit: We eventually narrowed it down to two suspects, one for each event, but my parents never asked them or tried to find out. We just stopped inviting them and if they did come, we locked the bedroom doors and kept an eye out.

moltomezzoforte

3. The Pen Pal Who Never Signed Their Letters

Who my “pen pal” was as a kid.

When I was about eight years old I started getting little notes in the mail every week or two. They were all stamped and addressed to me, and they all contained little doodles and said very random things such as “I like birthday cake, do you?” or “my favorite flowers are daisies, what are yours?” They were never signed and there was no return address. The handwriting didn’t look like anyone in my family or any of my friends, and every person I asked denied it.

Eventually my parents got visibly uncomfortable with it and would start insisting on examining the letters before I opened them. Pretty soon after that they stopped coming. Been nearly 20 years and still no idea what was up with that.

morbidcuriosities

4. The Cashier Who Looked Just Like Me

I once saw a cashier at my local supermarket, that looked oddly like me. I had a strong, nagging feeling that I somehow knew him fairly well, but I ignored it.

That was until I went to pay and he looked at me, squinted his eyes and asked me if we knew each other. I told him that I felt the same and we just sorta stood there, staring at each other, trying to figure out what was happening. Same build, hair, glasses, age… We ended up agreeing that we had no clue, I paid and went on with my life…

Never saw him again, even though I visited that specific supermarket multiple times afterwards…

Spooky, weird, wholesome. It still baffles me to this day.

Anonymous

5. The Text That Started A Ten-Year Relationship

I met my current partner of 10 years when she texted me because she didn’t know who’s number she had. We had never met before and to this day we have no idea how she got my number. maybe it was a typo?

Rebuta

6. The Egg That Came Out Of Nowhere

During a party I was throwing in 2014 one of my friends was hit in the head by an egg. She was standing in the backyard and an egg seemingly flew out of nowhere and cracked on her head.

Four years later, and no one has been able to venture a theory that does not require a wild stretch of imagination.

Anonymous

7. A Gift With No Name Attached

When I was in middle school someone doorbell ditched me a gift bag of gift cards. We saw the car drive away and it was didnt look like anyone we knew. There were about $200 in gift cards for me. Coming from a family of 7 that was in a cult (meaning 10% of our income went to the church) $200 was a huge gift. I remember going to Mervyns and buying brand new clothes and shoes when I usually had to buy from the thrift store. I still wonder to this day about who it was that gave me that gift.

monzanita

8. A Strange Call On A Camping Trip

I was out camping one time in southern France with my family. We’re from the Netherlands. After setting up the tent, checking out the area and everything my parents start cooking and I got some time off for myself. I was 15 or something, and just bought a new phone from my first job.

I was sitting in my own secluded little area playing some animal crossing, when suddenly my phone rang. I pick up and hear nothing, just some breathing. So I’m like “Hello, who’s this?”. And then I hear a small girl slightly sobbing, asking me “Do you know where my mommy is?”. The kid couldn’t have been older than 10. I got caught by surprise by that question so I just answered back with “what??”.

Then the phone hung up and nothing else followed after that.

Swazzoo

9. The Case Of The Missing Paper Towels

Once my flatmates and I bought a jumbo pack of like six rolls of kitchen paper, popped it on top of the fridge, and the next day the entire thing had vanished. Even when we totally emptied and cleaned the whole house to move out (including moving the fridge out to clean underneath and behind it), it never showed up. I find it deeply disturbing that the two most likely possibilities we came up with were:

  1. A six-pack of kitchen roll somehow fluttered halfway across the room to land in the bin, where all four of us failed to notice it all week
  2. The estate agent crept in in the middle of the night, stole it without touching anything else, and left congratulating himself on a successful heist

Like, I get that one of my flatmates probably just brought it all up to their room and lived in luxury for the rest of the year, but honestly, not knowing which of them has failed to own up to it for the last three years is like a constant shadow over our relationship.

happinessinthedark

10. How Did My Roommate’s Family Get In?

My roommate was gone for the weekend, and I was sleeping in, when his family somehow broke in to our apartment.

I always lock the door with the chain is the thing, so even if they had a key they shouldn’t have been able to get in, but they did. His Mom popped into my room, apologized, and then disappeared. When I got up later they were gone, but the door still had the chain locked on it.

I have absolutely no clue how they got in. I know they were there and I didn’t hallucinate the whole thing because they left some groceries for him.

My only theory is they crawled in through the balcony, but it just seems so farfetched.

Anonymous

11. The Tiny Elephant Nobody Recognized

When we were kids my sister and I had a big box of toy animals. We played with them every day and so knew every single toy in that box. One day my sister stood up from playing and underneath where she’d been sitting was a teeny tiny plastic elephant that we’d never seen before.

The only explanation we could come up with at the time was that she had given birth to it there and then. I still can’t think of a better one.

ModeHopper

12. The Braid From Gran Canaria

When I was six I was on a family holiday in Gran Canaria. It being the early 90’s I of course got a hair braid, of many colours! Glitter string, bright greens and reds, very tacky but I loved it!

Went to sleep that night, gone next morning.

Didn’t unravel, there was not a single thread in my bed, nor in the bins, hair wasn’t shorter in that part, it wasn’t cut off as a joke by my brothers.

If it was taken out I like to think I’d have woken up to someone pulling at my hair?

Asked my parents twenty years later ” if you took it out just say it, it’s been bothering me for years!”

Both absolutely deny it.

Same with my brothers.

In my head it was magic string and the lady who put it in was a witch who called her string back but yeah, that’s my child imagination travelled into my late twenties.

JohnCleesesMustache

13. The Family Friend Who Stopped Calling

Had a family friend whom i’d known forever. She had been a friend of my parents since over a decade before I was born.

When I was in my late teens she dropped all contact with us for absolutely no reason I can discern. Parents don’t know either. Her brother confirmed that she’s still alive and in the country, she just doesn’t want to talk to us anymore.

ThreeDucksInAManSuit

14. The Voice That Said “Stop”

I’m crossing the street to go home, and everything turns blue, like a blue lens over a camera, and time basically stops. All I hear is a female voice saying “Stop! Don’t move!” And everything returns to normal, while I’m still standing there in shock. A box truck flies past me at 60 miles per hour. Had that not happened, I would have been hit and killed on the spot. I don’t know what happened, nor do I know how.

Tehsyr

15. The Photo On My Pillow

I was about 10 years old and had a photo of myself with a horse in my wallet. I kept my wallet next to my bed. One day I went into my room and the photo of me was tore into pieces laying on my pillow. I was a sweet and shy girl and that broke my heart.

I never found out who did it or why. I still sometimes think about that moment.

Anonymous

16. The Sleeping Bag That Vanished In Norway

These answers make my comment look weird, but I’d really like to know what happened to our sleeping bag in Norway… We were camping on a mountain and while packing up in the morning my gf put our packed sleeping bags outside of the tent together with our other stuff like my camera and gopro. After finishing up we noticed one sleeping bag was missing. We weren’t too far from a ledge that went straight down, but for the sleeping bag to have rolled there and fallen it would’ve had to turn itself around and make enough speed to reach the ledge. We also looked over the edge and didn’t see the bright blue and yellow colours of the sleeping bag. We asked a group of campers not too far from us if they saw anyone take a sleeping bag, but they didn’t see anyone. Also, my camera and gopro were still there, so I suppose no one tried to steal anything… up until today the mountain guides haven’t found a sleeping bag that fits the description yet.

5GodsDown

17. Whatever Happened To Sherry?

What happened to Sherry. Sherry was a friend of mine twenty odd years ago. She moved to another state to live with a man she met online (back when this was a complete oddity). We stayed in touch for a few years, then she dropped off the face of the earth. From what I can tell no one has heard from her in about fifteen years.

onekrazykat

18. The High School Blood Typing Test

When we did blood typing back in high school biology, mine was not an option given my parents’ blood types. Mine has since been confirmed by red cross when donating, and my parents types were from reliable sources. I’m either a freak of nature, got swapped at birth, or that wasn’t my dad.

AkumaBengoshi

19. Two Hours Between “Looking Forward To It” And Getting Stood Up

On the night bus home after a night out, I struck up conversation with this guy. Turns out we had loads in common, lived nearby and he was really cute. As we got to his stop I said something like “would it be creepy of me to ask for your number?” he burst out laughing and said he wanted to ask me, but didn’t wanna be “that guy”, so we swapped numbers.

We went on a date after that and it’s one of the best dates I’ve been on, we laughed from beginning to end.

The following weekend there was a music festival that we were both going to. Death Cab For Cutie were playing at it and it was going to the first time seeing them live for both of us, so we agreed to meet up to watch Death Cab together.

The morning of the festival, he messaged me saying he couldn’t wait for Death Cab & he was looking forward to seeing me. We had a bit of a back-and-forth and agreed that I’d let him know once I got to the venue.

I got to the stage where Death Cab were playing, found an easily identifiable spot for him to find me and messaged him where I was… No response. About 10 minutes before they were due to go on, I gave him a call. No answer.

About a week after I told my sister about it, she said he’d probably lost his phone and didn’t have my number memorised, so I sent a final “Hey, it’s caca_milis_ hope you enjoyed the weekend” kinda message, no response.

I’d LOVE to know what happened in the 2 hours between “looking forward to seeing you” and standing me up.

caca_milis_

20. Are My Hot Wheels Still In That Vent?

Growing up, my bedroom was on the second floor of a two-story farmhouse.

I was big into Matchbox cars and Hot Wheels. I had a huge bucket of them, and loved playing with them.

At least once or twice, I inadvertently dropped a car down the heat vent. In an attempt to retrieve it, I traced the heat vent to the basement, where the duct turned 90 degrees and ran about 30 feet to the furnace.

There was no access panel anywhere in that length of ductwork, so I was never able to retrieve my car(s).

We moved out of that house when I was around 14 years old, back in the early 1990s. I still wonder whether they are still in that duct, and how I could possibly talk the current homeowners into somehow letting me cut my way into their ductwork to finally retrieve my beloved cars.

Cessnateur

21. The Grandfather I Never Knew

I don’t know who my grandfather is. The man who I have been calling (or rather, “had been”, as he passed away last year) “granddad” all my life isn’t a blood-relative. It’s never been an issue, everyone in the family knows, and when he married my grandmother, he adopted her children, they too took on his surname.
Alas, my grandmother also passed away a few years ago, so simply put, I will never know who my real grandfather is. But at the same time, it doesn’t matter to me; Blood or not, the man I called “granddad” for all my life is still and will always be my granddad.

neohylanmay

22. What Was Peeking Out Of The Bedroom?

What did I see briefly peeking out of my neighbor’s master bedroom when I was little? Thing had no face and it retracted just as fast as it had popped out. This was back in the 90’s, btw.

hiccup90

23. Why Did My Personal Trainer Block Me?

Why did my personal trainer block me on social media after we stopped training together? Considering the emotional intimacy we shared when training (I’m the only person with whom he’s ever gone in depth about his experiences when he was deployed twice in Afghanistan for example), was it because it bothered him to get so close to me?

And was this, as I strongly suspect, the reason he and his girlfriend broke up the week before he and I ceased training?

I will probably never know unfortunately.

JaniePage

24. My House Is Full Of Secrets

Three of my vacuum cleaner’s nozzles went missing and I have no clue what happened to them.
Same thing happened with the lid of my wastebin. Huge, flat, metal thing. Vanished.
One morning, I found all of my panties in the socks drawer. Boyfriend claims it wasn’t him and my cats aren’t clever enough for those kinds of shenanigans.
My house is full of secrets.

Icleanforheichou

25. The Blank Space On My Birth Certificate

Serious answer…I’m adopted. I’ve always wanted to know who my dad is. Moms name on birth certificate. No father listed.

luckycem80

26. The Dog Bag Holder I Left On The Table

I bought a two pack of those doggy poop bag holders shaped like a bone for walks. I put one up for future use. Adopted a second dog and dug it out to clip to the leash. I laid it on the table so I wouldn’t forget to do it and went to bed. Next morning it’s gone. Package and all. I’ve torn my house upside down looking for the thing but it’s nowhere to be found. I was last to bed and first up, so nobody else could have moved it.

Anonymous

27. What Was In That Ballpark Bathroom Stall?

I was at a baseball game and went in the washroom. A guy was leaving one of the stalls and said, “don’t go in that one, people are such animals!”
I went in the next one over, and while I was doing my thing, somebody went in the other one and screamed, “What the heck?!”
I wrestled with the idea of looking but decided against it, and now I’ll never know.

Calm_Canary

28. How Do You Get A Negative 57%?

How I got a negative 57% on my project in elementary school.

ray753

29. A Dad Who’s Never Been Heard Farting

In my 35 years ive never known my dad to fart. not even once.

hes also now allergic to dairy, as of the last 10 years. i surmise hes actually backed up with farts and has fart blood poisoning. but im no doctor.

rustbelt84

30. The Other Dog In The Bedroom Window

There’s a fuzzy rope or snake that follows me everywhere. I try and try to catch it but I never can. One time I did catch it and I think it bit me because it hurt and I yelped and mom and dad laughed at me for it.

Also, in the bedroom, there’s a window with another dog in it and he copies me and it’s so frustrating. The other dog won’t even come into the room, even if I bark at him.

dog_who_can_type