30 Thanksgiving Guest Fails That Made Dinner Awkward For Everybody
I think you should have to host Thanksgiving once before you’re allowed to ask what time we’re eating. Just one year of trying to get five things hot at the same time in an oven that comfortably fits one and a half. After that, you’ll understand why the person making dinner went a little quiet when you asked if there was room to warm up your dip.
And that’s a normal Thanksgiving problem. In this AskReddit thread, people remembered guests who showed up with a whole separate dinner and relatives who treated the leftovers like they’d already paid for them.
If you’re hosting Thursday, you might come away feeling pretty good about your guest list. I’d still count the pies before everybody gets there.
1. The Pies Never Made It To Dinner
My brother-in-law’s father went out to the refrigerator we keep in the garage and ate both pumpkin pies we made before dinner was even served.
2. The Wedding Video Had A Surprise Ending
I was at my wife’s uncle’s house for Thanksgiving, and his wife decided right after dinner to play their wedding video because it was also their anniversary weekend. She looks for half an hour to find the videotape, finds it, and gathers the whole dinner party, 25-ish people, in the back room.
Right as she’s walking down the aisle, midway down the aisle it goes fuzzy and cuts to Dale Earnhardt’s funeral. Uncle Joe used that tape to record Dale Earnhardt’s funeral. Granted, it was in the small Michigan town where the NASCAR track is, but still. Everyone froze in complete shock, and I started laughing and felt like I was in a sitcom, but it was real life.
3. The Costco Cheez-Its Went Missing
The woman my cousin had just married stole a Costco-sized box of individually wrapped Cheez-It packages from our garage. I just happened to notice they were gone when putting food in the fridge. I asked about it publicly and she locked up, started stuttering, and went to get them out of her car. She returned with the excuse, “I thought these were mine. I have a box just like them at home.”
4. She Was In Charge Of Dessert
She was responsible for bringing the dessert. She showed up three hours late, and instead of bringing dessert, she brought an open bag of frozen pierogis. It was a real downer.
5. The Wedding Announcement Came With A Denial
My cousin posted her new wedding pictures while sitting at the Thanksgiving dinner table. She hadn’t told any of us that she got married. My aunt said, “You got married??” She denied it.
6. Uncle Brought His Own Dinner
My uncle brought pizza to Thanksgiving because he didn’t like my grandma’s cooking. She had spent all day cooking our Thanksgiving meal, and he brought pizza! He, my aunt, and my cousins ate the pizza like it was nothing. My grandma went into the other room and cried.
7. The Leftovers Are Apparently A Performance Review
Every year my family “subconsciously” gives all the leftovers to whichever cousin isn’t doing the best in life.
I’ve gotten the leftovers for the last six years.
8. Two People Kept Leaving At The Same Time
My husband’s brother and his sister-in-law, who was married to his OTHER brother, always disappeared for about 20 to 40 minutes at the same time.
This happened for four years in a row before anyone got nosy enough to go looking for them.
Sister-in-law is now married to the Thanksgiving Hookup Brother.
9. Grandma Got A Kick Out Of The TV Prank
Someone (we never figured out who, though I suspect my younger cousin) set the TV to the Playboy Channel right as we were finishing up eating. This year we had so many people we had to eat in the living room, right next to the TV.
I don’t think I’ve ever seen my grandma laugh as much as she did when she saw everyone scrambling to find the clicker. 🙂
10. The Family Has A System For No-Shows
This isn’t an isolated thing, but if someone doesn’t show up for Thanksgiving or Christmas, we automatically check the inmate records at the county jail. It’s happened a few times that someone’s absence is accounted for by an arrest or jail stay.
In 2016 my brother was a no-show for Christmas and we checked the jail’s website. We saw our unique last name on their roster and assumed he’d been arrested. Turns out it was my uncle. I never did ask my brother where he was that year.
11. They Stopped For White Castle On The Way
We were hosting Thanksgiving and prepared all the food ourselves. My mom spent all morning cooking and baking. My aunt, uncle, and cousins arrive right before dinner and walk in with a White Castle case and say they just stopped to eat a few minutes ago. We had prepared Thanksgiving just for them, and they decided that they wanted White Castle instead.
12. Mom Interrupted The Prayer
My religious extended family were in deep prayer at the dinner table when my mom yelled, “F**k! The bread is burned!”
13. Someone Recognized The New Boyfriend
My sister-in-law’s mother brought her young boyfriend to our family Thanksgiving. Turns out the boyfriend was my cousin’s ex that she just broke up with a few weeks prior.
[deleted]
14. The Special Bread Was Apparently Mandatory
I have a cousin who came after not being invited and then yelled at everyone because no one brought the “special bread” her son likes and now he’s STARVING. Maybe bring your own Hawaiian sweet bread if that’s the only thing your kid will eat.
She then boxed up a large portion of the leftovers and left and was unseen until the next unfortunate family function.
15. The Gravy Was Optional
My uncle poured Crown Royal on his turkey and ate it.
16. The Brothers Took Out A Wall
My brothers got into a fight. My oldest brother slept with my younger brother’s new wife, who was like 20 years younger than him. They got into a fistfight and broke through the wall of their dad’s trailer. The police had to be called. Aaaand that’s why I stopped going to family evening. This was by no means an unusual occurrence, just the first thing that came to mind.
17. Uncle Had Been Planning This All Along
This was just a joke, but I still felt it was worth sharing. My uncle made a scene about having dropped something on the floor. When he was sure enough of us were now paying attention, he bends over to pick it up, his shirt rides up, and we see a tiger tattoo crawling out of the back of his pants. It was a temporary tattoo that he had my aunt help him put on specifically for this occasion.
18. The Buffet Decorations Started Moving
One Thanksgiving my family (my grandparents and my aunt’s family) were all eating at a buffet that was decorated extensively with a ton of gourds, pumpkins, and general Thanksgiving-y decorations. We all started taking them back to our table every time we went to the buffet table. We had our entire table covered before the staff started to notice. Trashy but hilarious!
[deleted]
19. The Host Had Something Else In Mind Before Dinner
I don’t think this constitutes as trashy, but my uncle hosted Thanksgiving last year. It was amidst all the drama about kneeling during the national anthem in the NFL. So naturally, instead of having a small prayer before dinner, he had us stand for the national anthem.
20. They Started Without Her
My aunt and uncle showed up an hour late to dinner. My aunt then proceeded to yell at all of us because we started eating without her. The rest of the family still makes jokes about it and some are still not on speaking terms with her.
21. The Dinner Conversation Came To A Sudden Stop
We were hosting a young lady my wife worked with, as well as her boyfriend. Halfway through dinner, the discussion somehow got to how she and her brother “once got super trashed on Robitussin, and next thing you know we… Uh… Yeah, that was a really weird time.”
Everyone just got really quiet as we were trying to decide how to fill that one in and where to go with it. For some reason they got really quiet after that.
22. There Was A Three-Hour Debate
My uncle and my cousin’s husband fought about flat earth for three hours.
23. The First Dinner With The In-Laws Was Awkward
My first Thanksgiving at my future in-laws’ house, when I was meeting most of them for the first time, his dad, who I had never met, commented on my chest multiple times, once referring to it as “pillows.” I was mortified.
24. The Turkey Went Home With One Person
Aunt took all of the leftover turkey, all of it.
25. He Thought He Was Talking To Someone Else
I told my girlfriend’s sister-in-law the bridesmaids’ dresses she picked out were tacky, thinking I was talking to someone else in the family. I proceeded to tell her they looked like Whoopi Goldberg in Sister Act. She still despises me.
26. She Tried To Start A Conversation
Big Thanksgiving dinner at the in-laws. Even my in-laws’ extended family members were there, and out of nowhere my mom tries to start a conversation with “I’m not a racist, but…” and I didn’t even hear the rest because I was laughing because she most definitely was a racist. That was the last year she was invited.
[deleted]
27. Aunt Tried To Come Back Downstairs
My aunt was sent to bed because she was too drunk last year and ended up falling down the stairs an hour later when she tried coming back.
28. He Made His Own Blend
I have an uncle who once got so drunk he decided to mix the red and white wines together.
29. Uncle Took His Turn During The Speeches
My drunk uncle got completely naked for the “what do you give thanks for” speeches. No joke. Best day ever.
30. Both Families Came Over For The First Time
Not sure if it counts, but my girlfriend and I were getting really serious and so our families had Thanksgiving together for the first time. It was a huge deal for us and our families and it was a great day. She broke up with me the next day.
